The dos and don'ts of Bitcoin key management
Bitcoin provides users with an incredibly high level of sovereignty over their money. You may have heard the phrase "be your own bank" which does a good job describing the power that Bitcoin enables its users to wield. The flip side is that being your own bank comes with a lot of responsibility. The same features that make Bitcoin so valuable (permissionlessness, censorship resistance, seizure resistance, etc.), also make it attractive to malicious actors. These malicious actors have come up with a wide variety of traps to fool bitcoin users into parting with their money, making bitcoin more challenging to use safely. The internet is a dangerous place, but we have the tools to protect ourselves!
Do take control
If you don't take possession of your own private keys, there's no way for you to truly know if they are secure. Any trusted third party such as an exchange is a black box to you.
When you entrust your keys to someone else, you might feel like you're ridding yourself of the risks that come with securing private keys. This is not the case — all of those threats still exist, but now you no longer have control over putting measures in place to stop them. Furthermore, your threat model actually expands because now there are additional risks to your money:
- Collusion against you by the custodian
- Internal attacks within the custodial organization
- External attacks incentivized by the custodian holding funds of many people
The rest of this post may feel daunting due to its length, but knowledge is power!
Do protect yourself
Practice strong cyber hygiene on all your online accounts. Assume that your usernames and passwords to every service will get leaked. Use a password manager (preferably one secured by hardware second factor authentication (2FA) such as a Yubikey), to generate unique passwords for every service. Similarly, add 2FA to every online account that supports it, preferably hardware-based 2FA. If a service only supports TOTP, then you can secure those secrets on hardware (a Yubikey) via Yubico Authenticator.
If you're not deeply familiar with best practices for cybersecurity and operational security, I recommend reading Jolly Roger's Security Guide For Beginners.
Understand the trade-offs between convenience and security when it comes to your private keys. A single-signature hot wallet on your phone is great for "carrying around" spending money but should not be used to store your life savings. On the other hand, a geographically-distributed multisig setup should be inconvenient enough to access that you only spend from it on a monthly or yearly basis.
Use dedicated hardware devices to store your private keys. Verify send addresses on dedicated hardware devices; don't trust addresses displayed in browsers or desktop software.
Be sure to check the entire destination address when sending, not just the first few characters. There are many types of malware that will try to swap out your intended address for a similar-looking one owned by the malware authors.
Develop a solid plan for how to recover from disaster scenarios. This may involve a seed phrase backup scheme for which there are a variety of cold storage guides. We're not a fan of users having to manage seed phrase data; we explain why in this post.
If you choose to store your seed phrase backups on metal devices, make sure you buy one that has been stress tested and shown to survive extreme environments!
Verify that the software you install is authentic and not a malicious lookalike. Unfortunately, verifiability is different for every platform. For desktop software, you can verify GPG signatures if you're comfortable with command line use. Mobile apps are generally cryptographically signed, but that signature is only verified by the app store. To prevent installing an imposter mobile app, go to the web site of the company and click on a link to install the mobile app from their site.
Don't get phished
Don't type your seed phrase into any computer that is connected to the internet! Especially not into a web browser! Now that many bitcoin users are protecting their keys with dedicated hardware devices, we're seeing attackers go after the biggest remaining weakness: the human operator.
Typosquatting is a lesser-known attack vector where malicious actors will buy domains that are close misspellings of common bitcoin web services. You should only visit financial web sites via bookmarks to ensure that you don't accidentally end up on a typosquatter's malicious site.
Similar to typosquatting is an issue where malicious sites pay for search engine advertisements, thus bumping up their sites before the normal search results. This is another reason to bookmark the sites you use rather than using a search engine to visit them; you might accidentally click on a malicious link.
Don't install malware
Avoid installing many browser extensions; they can easily be malicious and see all of your browsing activity.
Don't use wallets that are browser extensions; they may be outright scams.
Don't run software wallets on a desktop machine that has lots of other software installed. You increase the risk of other software being compromised via dependency injection that will install clipboard malware and trojans that scan your computer for private keys.
Don't fall victim to ransomware that hijacks your hard drive. Only install authentic software and make sure you back up your hard drive regularly so that you can recover data in the event that you lose access to your data.
Don't use web-based QR code generators — especially not "bitcoin QR code generators" — since they may replace your address with their own.
Do verify the authenticity of any software you install, if at all possible. This means checking file hashes and GPG signatures on any binaries that you download. Do not install software to hold your private keys if you can't verify what it's doing. This includes things like running AWS images that are maintained by third parties.
Don't create technical weaknesses
Most users should not store private key backups digitally; especially not in an online service. While it is possible to create secure digital backups, you need to be an advanced user in order to so safely.
We recommend against using browser-based wallets, even if it's just a browser interface to a hardware wallet; the attack surface for browsers is huge.
Similarly, if you're using Tor browser to access a web service that displays bitcoin addresses for deposits, you should be aware that malicious Tor relays could swap out addresses for their own.
Don't use brain wallets — humans are terrible at generating entropy! If you send funds to a brain wallet composed of common English words, it will likely be stolen in seconds.
Don't use Shamir's Secret Sharing; it has many downsides that I go into detail here:
Don't manually split up your seed phrases; it drastically reduces their security against being brute forced.
Don't get creative and try to obfuscate your seed backups. You'll likely degrade the security and run the risk of data loss. I go into depth with one example in this post:
Along a similar vein, don't bother randomizing your backed-up seed phrases; depending upon the seed phrase length it would be trivial to detect and brute force given that seed phrases have built-in checksums. For example, a 12-word phrase only has 500 million combinations, of which perhaps 50,000 would be valid; a sophisticated attacker would be able to check them all for funds in a matter of minutes.
Don't use paper wallets. They're very hard to use securely and it's easy to accidentally lose funds if you don't understand all the risks.
One common theme we've seen with new Casa clients is that they have split up their funds across a variety of single signature hardware devices or paper wallets. While this does decrease your risk of catastrophic loss it actually increases your risk of partial loss. Don't believe that distributing your keys across many single points of failure is safe.
Don't get scammed
Don't believe scareware/blackmail messages, even if they include your username and password to various services — those are taken from database leaks that get sold on the dark web. At time of writing, the latest variant of these are "sextortion scams" that will claim that they installed malware on your computer and recorded embarrassing images of you.
Steer clear of "bitcoin doubling" scams. Nobody is going to take your bitcoin and then give even more back to you for the pleasure of holding onto your money for a matter of minutes. The time value of money simply isn't that high.
Don't try to collect airdrops; they may be fake. Some may try to phish for your credentials to online wallets/services. More sophisticated scams will be malware wallets that steal your bitcoin. The only safe way to collect airdropped forkcoins from a wallet is after you have moved your bitcoin to a completely new wallet.
Avoid the temptation to send bitcoin to mixer web sites; most are scams. Mixing can only be done safely by running your own mixing software so that you retain control of your private keys. JoinMarket, Wasabi, and Whirlpool are several such examples.
Don't invest in Initial Coin Offerings without performing plenty of due diligence. A Bloomberg research report concluded that 80% of ICOs have been fraudulent.
Similarly, don't fall victim to greed and participate in "pump and dump" groups the most likely outcome of such activity will be that a few insiders end up profiting and you end up losing your money.
Don't buy hardware wallets from resellers. Similarly, don't initialize hardware wallets with seed phrases supplied to you by a third party.
Don't get hacked
Don't install remote-access software like Teamviewer on any of your computers.
Don't be a target
Don't make yourself a target by talking about your bitcoin. For example, Cody posted this tweet about a friend whose Coinbase account was hacked. Unfortunately, he leaked the info that he also had a funded Coinbase account.
Within a few days, he was SIM swapped and his Coinbase account was similarly drained.
Along the same vein of phone security — avoid connecting your phone number to any online accounts; an attacker could SIM swap your phone number and use it to break into those accounts via password resets. This is so common that it's not even funny any more; when I worked at BitGo we caught onto this trend early and removed SMS functionality from our platform. And yet, 3 years later, a BitGo engineer fell victim to this same vulnerability (with their Coinbase account).
Security is a Dynamic Environment
The battles between attackers and defenders are constantly changing as they innovate new tactics and force the opposing side to respond.
If you're feeling overwhelmed by the magnitude of threats to your bitcoin, have no fear — we have architected Casa's self-custody solution to mitigate them:
If you're looking for a consultation on your Bitcoin security setup, Casa Client Services are ready to help! Our premium tiers of service include dedicated Client Advisors who will work with you to customize your setup to your specific needs. You can get started here!
Want more tips on Bitcoin security? You can join the Casa Security Briefing for a weekly update on news + developments impacting your personal security and privacy.
The Services are a platform for managing cryptographic keys and nodes. The Services are not an exchange for buying, selling, or trading digital or virtual currency or assets (an “Exchange”), and Casa is not a bank or other financial institution. The Services do not and cannot sell, hold, invest, send or receive money or cause or effect any digital or virtual currency or asset transactions. BY USING THE SERVICES IN ANY MANNER, YOU ACKNOWLEDGE AND AGREE THAT (A) CASA IS NOT IN THE BUSINESS OF PROVIDING FINANCIAL, LEGAL, TAX, ACCOUNTING, OR INVESTMENT ADVICE OR SERVICES, (B) NONE OF THE SERVICES ARE INTENDED TO PROVIDE OR CONTAIN ANY SUCH ADVICE OR SERVICES, AND (C) ANY AND ALL SERVICES ARE PROVIDED FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY. Casa urges you to consult a qualified professional for any such advice or service.